Friday, January 17, 2014




The New Year is a time when many of us naturally take a look back at the previous year. Reflecting on our relationships, health, finances and professional life commonly results in the creation of resolutions with the intent to better ourselves during the next 12 months. A clear focus, solid action plan, and the ability to adjust that plan are essential for the success of a New Year’s resolution.


Just like resolutions, the specificity and intentionality of the work educators do will largely predict the outcome. Through the learning cycle, Wilson teachers are engaged in a cycle of planning instruction, assessing students and responding to that assessment data. All of these steps are essential for us to reach our goal of improving student achievement.


I recently visited two eighth grade science classrooms in which this was artfully implemented. Students were engaged (ALL students in both classes) in completing an assessment that involved reading, formulating an opinion and writing a conclusion with cited evidence. Students were given the following prompt:
    • Mrs. Schmidt believes that keeping endangered tigers in a zoo is helpful.
    • Mrs. Richards believes that keeping endangered tigers in a zoo is harmful.
    • Use evidence to support both claims. (several articles were provided)
    • Write a paragraph supporting which teacher’s claim you agree with the most.
Phase 2 of the Learning Cycle (Assessment/ Student Work/ Feedback) as printed on the Wilson Look Fors states, “Students will respond to teacher’s comments, edit the product, justify their responses,and self assess using rubrics.” All aspects of this Look For were observed in both of these science classrooms that day. Students were engaged in writing, editing and justifying their thinking with cited evidence.


When I asked a student why they were doing this assignment, he told me that it is important to know that the decisions we make can have an effect on an entire ecosystem. Now that is big picture thinking! The perfect alignment of the I Can statement with the activity (I can evaluate the impact that human interactions have on an ecosystem.) undoubtedly communicated a clear rationale for the activity.


Another example of Phase 2 evidence came from asking a student the following question. “How do you know if you are writing a good paragraph?” He responded by referencing the rubric that was among the assignment documents and explaining how to use the rubric to judge his work. Again, another example of evidence pointing to intentional planning.


Mrs. Richards took this process one step further. The Wilson Look Fors has the following description of teacher behaviors that will demonstrate implementation of Phase 3 (Response to Data). Teachers will use a variety of the following in order to respond to non-proficient students: guided groups, reteaching in groups, use assessment data for grouping, refer to backward plan, implementing Tier 1 interventions. During my visit to Mrs. Richards’ classroom, I observed her conferring with a student, one-on-one as he completed his assessment.  It was clear that because of her formative assessment data, she was aware of this student’s need for additional support and determined how she would support him.


In the words of Ellen DeGenerous: “You shouldn’t be allowed to make any New Year’s resolutions until you finish your old ones.” All the teachers at Wilson Middle School are engaged in the learning cycle: there is no need for a New Years’ resolution. We continue to focus on our current resolution...to improve student learning through the continuous cycle of planning, assessing and responding through purposeful guided grouping based on the formative assessment data.


Content team meetings are perfect for continuing this work. We must not only look at the data, but be intentional about our guided groups. James-Ward, Fisher, Frey and Lapp wrote in their book Using Data to Focus Instructional Improvement, “No student should have to wait until the first reporting period is over before being noticed as a struggling student.” How long is it before you know that a student is struggling and what are you doing about it?

There is great work happening at Wilson! Reflect, celebrate the successes and adjust as necessary to reach all students so we can reach our goal.

7 comments:

  1. This was a great activity that the 8th grade Science did. If fact, a lot of students were talking about this outside of the classroom. The best part of what the Science teachers did was to help encourage students to write persuasively using text supports. Argumentative writing is the current focus in 8th grade literacy. It is so wonderful to know that students are using "Literacy" across the content areas.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The students were talking about it in other classes, and they seemed to really like the activity. It was nice to hear about it from the students.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I was honored to also visit these classrooms with Mrs. Bryson! The clear relationship between implementation of the learning team and the classroom was a model for the effectiveness of learning teams. Not only do teacher benefit from the collaboration by creating a shared meaning of student learning, but students also benefit from engaging in experiences that reflect deeper levels of instructional intentionality!

    Keep up the great work, Wilson!

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is an awesome example of how the content teachers can support our literacy standards. I think it is awesome that you were having students cite specific evidence from the text. Exciting!

    ReplyDelete
  5. This blog showcases what can happen when there is a clear purpose for what students need to learn and apply during a unit. There were skills students needed to practice and concepts students needed to struggle with in order to create student learning. Students found the activity engaging and were able to complete it with high levels of thinking and writing. This validates the planning, lessons, and activities that occurred during the unit which were aided by the learning team cycle. Students had to have been exposed to high level tasks throughout the unit because they were able to confidently respond to the prompts they were given. The fact students were talking about the task outside of the science classroom speaks to the authenticity and ownership of the task.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Neat activity! It is great to hear about the high student interest and engagement.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Great job 8th grade science! Way to represent a way for students to fully engage in this activity and making it cross curricular, allowing for them to strengthen their skills of debate and reason. Great job Whitney and Kari! The cycle of assessment can often be difficult in science, but with an activity like this, it would be a great foundation to gain understanding of what students truly know - and if they are able to apply it!

    ReplyDelete